State & Local Corruption

Where most corruption lives; and where oversight is thinnest.

~500,000
Elected Officials Nationwide
90,000+
Local Government Units
~25,000
State/Local Convictions (1976–2022)
1,300+
Newspaper Closures (2004–2023)

Why State and Local Corruption Is Underreported

The paradox of American corruption is that it is most prevalent where it is least visible. The overwhelming majority of government decisions that affect daily life, zoning, building permits, police conduct, school budgets, water treatment, road contracts, code enforcement, are made at the state and local level. Yet these levels of government receive a fraction of the oversight directed at federal officials.

The Collapse of Local Journalism

The single most important factor in the underreporting of local corruption is the collapse of local journalism. According to Northwestern University's Medill School of Journalism:

  • More than 2,500 newspapers have closed since 2005, including over 1,300 since 2014.
  • The number of newspaper journalists has dropped from approximately 71,000 in 2006 to fewer than 31,000 in 2022; a 56% decline.
  • Over 200 counties in the United States have no local news coverage at all; "news deserts" that collectively contain over 3.2 million residents.
  • An additional 1,630 counties have only one remaining local news source, typically a weekly publication with minimal investigative capacity.[1]

A 2018 study published in the Journal of Financial Economics found a direct link: in counties where local newspapers closed, municipal borrowing costs increased (reflecting higher risk) and public officials were more likely to engage in financial mismanagement. The study estimated that the absence of a local newspaper cost the average community $1.8 million per year in higher borrowing costs alone.[2]

Structural Oversight Gaps

  • Inspector General offices: Only 33 states have independent Inspectors General. Many state and local governments have no independent audit or oversight function.
  • Ethics commissions: While all 50 states have some form of ethics law, enforcement varies dramatically. Twelve states have ethics commissions with no independent investigatory authority. Several states, including Idaho and Wyoming, have no ethics commission at all.[3]
  • Whistleblower protections: Vary widely by state. Twenty-two states provide protections that are rated "weak" or "minimal" by the National Conference of State Legislatures.

Most Corrupt Cities: The Historical Record

Using DOJ conviction data, FBI public corruption statistics, and academic studies, several cities consistently emerge as the most corruption-prone in American history.

Chicago, Illinois

Chicago / Cook County
Northern District of Illinois
95
The Northern District of Illinois, centered on Chicago, has produced more public corruption convictions than any other federal judicial district in the United States. From 1976 through 2022, the district recorded over 1,750 public corruption convictions — an average of nearly 40 per year for 46 consecutive years.

Chicago's corruption is not merely historical. It is structural, deeply embedded in the city's political culture, and continuously renewing:

  • Four of the last seven Illinois governors have been criminally charged: Otto Kerner (convicted 1973), Dan Walker (convicted 1987), George Ryan (convicted 2006), and Rod Blagojevich (convicted 2011).
  • Over 30 Chicago aldermen have been convicted of corruption-related crimes since 1972; out of a 50-member City Council.
  • Ed Burke, the longest-serving alderman in Chicago history (54 years), was convicted in 2023 of racketeering, bribery, and extortion. He used his position as Finance Committee chairman to steer property tax business to his private law firm.[4]

New Orleans, Louisiana

New Orleans and Louisiana rank consistently as the most corrupt city and state per capita in academic studies. A 2019 study by the University of Illinois at Chicago examined DOJ conviction data from 1976 to 2018 and ranked Louisiana first among states in per-capita federal corruption convictions.[5]

  • Edwin Edwards: four-term governor, convicted in 2000 of extortion, fraud, and racketeering related to riverboat casino licensing. Sentenced to 10 years.
  • Ray Nagin: New Orleans mayor (2002–2010), convicted in 2014 of bribery, fraud, and tax evasion related to post-Katrina rebuilding contracts. Sentenced to 10 years.
  • William Jefferson: U.S. Representative, convicted in 2009 after FBI agents found $90,000 in cash wrapped in aluminum foil in his freezer.

Newark, New Jersey

New Jersey has produced more public corruption convictions per capita than nearly any other state. Newark, its largest city, has seen a succession of corrupt officials:

  • Hugh Addonizio: mayor (1962–1970), convicted of extortion and conspiracy. He accepted kickbacks from contractors worth millions.
  • Sharpe James: mayor (1986–2006), convicted in 2008 of conspiring to rig the sale of city-owned land to his companion.
  • The broader New Jersey corruption ecosystem includes former governors, state legislators, and an extensive 2009 FBI sting ("Operation Bid Rig") that resulted in the arrest of 44 individuals, including three mayors, two state legislators, and five rabbis in a corruption and money-laundering scheme.[6]

Detroit, Michigan

  • Kwame Kilpatrick: mayor (2002–2008), convicted in 2013 of racketeering, extortion, and bribery in one of the largest public corruption cases in Michigan history. Prosecutors documented a pay-to-play scheme involving city contracts worth hundreds of millions. Originally sentenced to 28 years (later commuted by President Trump in 2021).[7]
  • Monica Conyers: City Council president pro tem, pleaded guilty in 2009 to bribery related to a sludge-hauling contract.

Baltimore, Maryland

Baltimore / Maryland
District of Maryland
90
Baltimore has produced a pattern of systemic corruption spanning its police department and consecutive mayors. The Gun Trace Task Force scandal stands as one of the worst police corruption cases in American history, while two mayors in succession were convicted of financial crimes — creating a crisis of institutional legitimacy across the city.

Gun Trace Task Force (BPD)

Gun Trace Task Force
Baltimore Police Department — Specialized Unit
92
8 Officers Convicted Racketeering Robbery Extortion Overtime Fraud
Eight Baltimore Police Department officers were convicted of racketeering, robbery, extortion, and overtime fraud in one of the most brazen police corruption cases in modern American history. The officers operated as a criminal enterprise within the department, robbing citizens, stealing from drug dealers, planting evidence, and filing false overtime claims. Combined sentences totaled 112 years in federal prison. Four additional BPD officers were convicted for cover-up activities. Civil settlements reached approximately $2.5 million in 2024. The scandal inspired HBO's acclaimed series We Own This City.[14]

Individual sentences:

  • Sgt. Wayne Jenkins (ringleader); 25 years federal prison.
  • Daniel Hersl: 18 years (convicted at trial, refused to cooperate).
  • Marcus Taylor: 18 years (convicted at trial, refused to cooperate).
  • Thomas Allers: 15 years.
  • Jemell Rayam: 12 years.
  • Momodu Gondo: 10 years (cooperating witness).
  • Maurice Ward: 7 years (cooperating witness).
  • Evodio Hendrix: 7 years (cooperating witness).

Mayors

  • Catherine Pugh: mayor (2016–2019), orchestrated the "Healthy Holly" scheme. Pugh self-published children's books and sold bulk copies to nonprofits, hospitals, and entities with business before the city at inflated prices, generating approximately $800,000 in total revenue. Pleaded guilty to federal conspiracy, fraud, and tax evasion charges. Sentenced to 3 years federal prison in February 2020. Ordered to pay $411,000+ in restitution and forfeit $670,000.[15]
  • Sheila Dixon: mayor (2007–2010), convicted December 1, 2009 of misdemeanor embezzlement for stealing approximately $530 in gift cards intended for needy families. Resigned January 2010 as part of a plea agreement. Sentenced to 4 years probation and 500 hours community service.

Prince George's County

  • Jack B. Johnson: County Executive (2002–2010), pleaded guilty to extortion and evidence tampering in May 2011. Sentenced to 87 months federal prison. Johnson accepted between $400,000 and $1 million in bribes from real estate developers seeking county approvals. When FBI agents arrived to execute a search warrant, Johnson called his wife and instructed her to flush a $100,000 check and hide cash in her underwear. Agents recovered $79,600 from her undergarments.[16]
  • Will Campos: Councilman and State Delegate, sentenced to 54 months federal prison for bribery conspiracy (2018).
  • Tawanna P. Gaines: State Delegate, defrauded her campaign of $22,000+ by routing funds through a personal PayPal account.

Mayor Brandon Scott (2020–Present): Mounting Controversies

Brandon Scott, elected in 2020 as Baltimore's youngest mayor in over a century on an anti-corruption platform, now faces his own mounting controversies involving his office's spending, obstruction of the city's watchdog, program fraud, campaign finance violations, and conflicts of interest. While no criminal charges have been filed against Scott personally, the pattern of allegations has drawn comparisons to his predecessors.

Mayor Brandon Scott
Mayor of Baltimore (2020–Present)
58
Under Investigation / IG Lawsuit Filed Obstruction Spending Abuse Cronyism Campaign Finance
Baltimore's youngest mayor in over a century ran on a promise to clean up City Hall. Instead, his administration faces an unprecedented lawsuit from the city's own Inspector General over obstruction of fraud investigations, alongside revelations of lavish office spending, program fraud, campaign finance violations, and conflicts of interest involving his wife's nonprofit.
Inspector General Lawsuit (Feb 2026)

In an unprecedented move, Inspector General Isabel Mercedes Cumming filed a lawsuit (Cumming et al. v. Mayor & City Council of Baltimore City) in Baltimore Circuit Court on February 24, 2026, after the Scott administration systematically cut off her office's access to city records:[32]

  • Scott's administration cut OIG access to city records in June 2025; the first time in Cumming's tenure since 2018.
  • The OIG issued a subpoena on January 20, 2026 for MONSE financial records; the city responded with 200+ pages of mostly redacted information.
  • Scott further restricted OIG access on February 6, 2026, citing a Maryland Attorney General advice letter.
  • Maryland AG Anthony Brown distanced himself from the advice letter, stating it "could have been written by a second-year law student."
  • The OIG Citizens Advisory Board (11 members) publicly backed Cumming.
  • Cumming stated that 104 of 324 investigations relied on information now being restricted; those 104 cases had identified approximately $38.9 million in fraud, waste, or abuse.[33]
MONSE/SideStep Program Fraud
  • $694,798.86 paid to 15 community-based contractors.
  • At least 2 of 15 contractors committed fraud; altered invoices to receive larger payments.
  • Data breach: 701 names (mostly juveniles) with dates of birth and criminal charges leaked by a former MONSE employee to a relative's personal email.
  • Fraud findings referred to law enforcement for criminal investigation (March 2026).[34]
Safe Streets Program — FBI Investigation
  • October 26, 2023: FBI raided the Bel Air-Edison Safe Streets location investigating Black Guerrilla Family (BGF) gang connections.
  • Site supervisor David Caldwell charged after the raid; ammunition, computers, and drug packaging material seized.
  • BGF-Safe Streets connections documented since 2010.
  • Former Safe Streets employee Ricky Evans pleaded guilty to federal charges including authorizing murders from a Safe Streets office (2018).
  • Fictitious names in contracts (OIG, Nov 2024): 26 potentially fake employee names identified; 9 employees budgeted for $285,000 couldn't be verified. Names included plays on professional athletes: "Allen Iverson," "Lemur Jackson" (Lamar Jackson), "Merlin Humphrey" (Marlon Humphrey).
  • $290,357 in duplicate payments to Safe Streets contractors found by the Department of Audits.
  • $257,000+ in unverified worker payments.[35]
$890,176 in Office Spending (OIG Report, Feb 25, 2026)
Mayor's Office Spending — OIG Report Findings
  • $801,839 on meals and catering.
  • $42,691 on floral arrangements and funeral services.
  • $52,588.78 on food/beverages at Ravens and Orioles box suites.
  • $33,000+ on flowers for staff birthdays, bereavements, and baby announcements.
  • $3,636 farewell party for former chief of staff (included $324 balloon arch, $217 cake).
  • 336 P-card transactions violated city procurement rules.
  • $167,455.06 in charges without required waivers.
  • Plus $310,785 on community events and $187,272 on t-shirts, backpacks, and promotional items.

Scott's response: "Nothing illegal was done here."[34]

$163,495 Taxpayer-Funded Vehicle
  • 2025 Jeep Grand Wagoneer: $98,716 vehicle + $64,779 security modifications.
  • Most expensive government vehicle in all of Maryland; exceeds Governor Moore's ($82,141) by $81,000+.
  • Purchased while the city closed an $85 million budget deficit through fines and fees on residents.
  • 14 MPG despite Scott's climate advocacy.
  • Scott called a reporter's questions about the vehicle "racist" and compared it to the presidential limousine.[36]
Campaign Finance Violations
  • At least 8–9 donors exceeded Maryland's $6,000 per election cycle limit, totaling approximately $26,000 over legal limits.
  • $5,000 donation from J.P. Grant (October 2022), the same businessman involved in former Mayor Pugh's "Healthy Holly" corruption, just weeks before the Board of Estimates added $12 million to a Grant-linked contract.
  • Former chief public corruption investigator James Cabezas filed a formal ethics complaint about the Grant donation.
  • Scott had previously returned $4,500 from Grant in 2019, pledging to "clean up government."[33]
Conflicts of Interest — Wife's Nonprofit
  • Mayor's wife Hana Scott served as Director of Operations at Bmore Empowered (September 2021–September 2025).
  • The nonprofit received approximately $100,000 in taxpayer funds, including $62,500 from the Baltimore Children and Youth Fund (BCYF).
  • Bmore Empowered subsequently ceased operations, fell behind on tax filings, and was sued for unpaid rent.
  • Experts described the arrangement as rife with "giant red flags."
  • 4 of 8 BCYF board members have direct ties to the mayor's office; BCYF has no financial audits on file for FY2022–2024.[36]
Calvin Young — Cronyism Allegations
  • Scott's former campaign treasurer hired as senior advisor at $140,000/year (September 2024).
  • Failed to file mandatory ethics disclosure; 118 days past due.
  • Promoted to Chief of Staff with a 79% salary increase to $250,000/year.
  • Former EBDI VP filed EEOC discrimination complaint alleging racially motivated firing by Young.[37]
State's Attorney Rift
  • State's Attorney Ivan Bates terminated coordination with MONSE (December 2025), accusing the office of operating behind a "veil of secrecy."
  • Bates cited MONSE's refusal to share potentially exculpatory evidence (Brady obligation).
  • Two separate legal battles over MONSE records headed to court simultaneously.[38]
The Pattern Continues: Baltimore has now had three consecutive mayors embroiled in corruption controversies. Sheila Dixon resigned after embezzlement. Catherine Pugh served federal prison time. Brandon Scott faces an unprecedented lawsuit from his own inspector general over obstruction of fraud investigations. Scott ran on a promise to clean up City Hall.

Minnesota

Minneapolis Police Department Corruption

The murder of George Floyd on May 25, 2020 exposed a police department with deep systemic problems that went far beyond a single officer. Federal investigations subsequently revealed entrenched patterns of misconduct, discrimination, and institutional failure.

  • Derek Chauvin: convicted of second-degree murder in state court, sentenced to 22.5 years. Subsequently convicted in federal court of civil rights violations, sentenced to 245 months (concurrent). Also pleaded guilty to tax evasion.
  • Thomas Lane (co-defendant); 2.5 years federal prison for civil rights violations.
  • J. Alexander Kueng (co-defendant); 3 years federal prison for civil rights violations.
  • Tou Thao (co-defendant); 3.5 years federal prison for civil rights violations.
DOJ Pattern-and-Practice Investigation (June 16, 2023)

The Department of Justice found that the Minneapolis Police Department engaged in a "pattern or practice" of using unjustified deadly force, discrimination against Black and Native American people, and violations of free speech rights. Key findings: officers stopped Black and Native American people at 6 times the rate of white people. Of 1,490 complaints filed against officers, only 29 resulted in any discipline. A consent decree was approved on January 6, 2025. The Trump administration's DOJ subsequently moved to dismiss the consent decree.[17]

Feeding Our Future — Largest Pandemic Relief Fraud in U.S. History

Feeding Our Future Fraud Scheme
District of Minnesota — USDA Federal Child Nutrition Program
90
63+ Convicted Wire Fraud Conspiracy Money Laundering Bribery
A $250 million fraud scheme — the largest pandemic relief fraud in American history. The nonprofit Feeding Our Future submitted fabricated meal count sheets to the USDA Federal Child Nutrition Program, claiming to feed tens of thousands of children who were never served. In total, 78+ defendants were charged and 63+ convicted in what became the most prosecuted single fraud scheme arising from the pandemic era.[18]

Key convictions:

  • Aimee Bock (founder of Feeding Our Future); found guilty on all counts March 19, 2025, including wire fraud, conspiracy, and bribery. Ordered to forfeit $5.2 million including a Porsche.
  • Salim Said: found guilty on all counts alongside Bock.
  • Abdimajid Mohamed Nur: 10 years federal prison.
  • Mohamed Ismail: 12 years federal prison, $47 million+ restitution.
  • Mukhtar Shariff: 17.5 years federal prison (money laundering).
The Broader Minnesota Fraud Epidemic

Feeding Our Future was only the largest of multiple pandemic-era fraud schemes centered in Minnesota. Federal investigators also uncovered massive fraud in emergency housing programs, autism therapy billing, home health care, Medicaid reimbursement, and daycare subsidy programs. Across all schemes, at least 92 people have been charged and 62+ convicted. The concentration of fraud in Minnesota has prompted congressional inquiries and DOJ task force investigations into why the state became an epicenter of pandemic-era fraud.[19]

Political Corruption

  • State Senator Omar Fateh: failed to disclose a $1,000 campaign payment. His brother-in-law was convicted of perjury related to absentee ballot irregularities. Fateh returned $11,000 in donations linked to individuals connected to the Feeding Our Future fraud scheme.
  • City Council Member Jamal Osman: founded a nonprofit that was later used to fraudulently obtain $10 million+ in federal funds through the child nutrition program.

California

California
Statewide Corruption — Multiple Jurisdictions
85
California's corruption spans the full spectrum: city hall pay-to-play schemes in Los Angeles, public works bribery in San Francisco, the extraordinary Bell salary scandal, state legislature arms trafficking, utility company felony manslaughter, and the largest municipal bankruptcy in American history. The state's size and economic power amplify the scale of each scandal.

Los Angeles City Hall — "Operation Casino Loyale"

FBI "Operation Casino Loyale"
Los Angeles City Council — Central District of California
85
Multiple Convicted RICO Conspiracy Bribery Tax Evasion
A sweeping FBI investigation into pay-to-play corruption at Los Angeles City Hall, centered on developer bribes to city council members in exchange for favorable zoning and land-use decisions. The investigation produced convictions of a sitting councilmember, a deputy mayor, and other officials, exposing how real estate development decisions in America's second-largest city were routinely for sale.[20]
  • Jose Huizar (Councilmember, CD14, 2005–2020); pleaded guilty to RICO conspiracy and tax evasion. Sentenced to 13 years federal prison (January 2024). Accepted $1.5 million+ in bribes from real estate developers seeking favorable zoning decisions. Also accepted a $600,000 bribe to settle a sexual harassment lawsuit brought against him.
  • Raymond Chan (Deputy Mayor); convicted of bribery, racketeering, fraud, and lying to the FBI. Sentenced to 12 years federal prison.
  • Mitchell Englander (Councilmember, CD12); 14 months federal prison for lying to FBI agents about $15,000 in cash payments and a Las Vegas trip provided by a businessperson.
  • Mark Ridley-Thomas (Councilmember, former County Supervisor); found guilty on 7 of 19 counts including conspiracy, bribery, and honest services fraud. Sentenced to 42 months federal prison. Conspired to get his son a scholarship and faculty position at USC in exchange for supporting a USC county contract.[21]

San Francisco Corruption

  • Mohammed Nuru (Public Works Director, 2011–2020); sentenced to 7 years federal prison. Accepted more than $1 million over 12 years from contractors seeking city business. Lost his $7,600/month pension. The investigation led to charges against 12+ additional San Francisco employees and contractors.[22]
  • Harlan Kelly (PUC Chief); 4 years federal prison (2024). Bribed by a contractor seeking streetlight maintenance contracts.
  • Paul Giusti (Recology executive); pleaded guilty to bribery and money laundering as part of the broader San Francisco public corruption investigation.

Bell, California Salary Scandal

  • Robert Rizzo (City Manager); illegally raised his salary from $300,000 to $800,000 per year in a city where the median household income was $24,800. Charged with 69 counts. Sentenced to 12 years state prison plus 33 months federal prison for tax evasion. Ordered to pay $8.8 million in restitution. Total cost to Bell taxpayers: an estimated $15 million.[23]
  • Angela Spaccia (Assistant City Manager); 11 years 8 months state prison for her role in the salary scheme.

State Legislature

  • Leland Yee (State Senator, San Francisco); caught in an FBI sting operation and convicted of racketeering charges involving money laundering, arms trafficking, and bribery. Sentenced to 5 years federal prison (2016). Yee, who had publicly advocated for gun control legislation, was recorded by undercover agents agreeing to facilitate illegal firearms imports from the Philippines.[24]
  • Andrew Do (Orange County Supervisor); pleaded guilty in October 2024 to bribery conspiracy. Steered $10 million+ in COVID relief funds to organizations that paid him and his daughter kickbacks. Accepted $550,000+ in bribes. Sentenced to 5 years federal prison.

PG&E Criminal Conduct

Pacific Gas & Electric: Corporate Felonies with Fatal Consequences

PG&E, California's largest utility, has been convicted of multiple federal and state felonies resulting in mass casualties; a record unmatched by any other American utility company:

  • San Bruno pipeline explosion (2010): 8 people killed, 58 injured, 38 homes destroyed. PG&E convicted of multiple federal felonies for knowingly operating deteriorated gas pipelines. Fined $1.6 billion.
  • Camp Fire (2018): 84 people killed, the town of Paradise largely destroyed; the deadliest and most destructive wildfire in California history. PG&E pleaded guilty to 84 felony counts of involuntary manslaughter. Fined $3.5 million (widely criticized as grossly inadequate). Filed for bankruptcy, ultimately establishing a $13.5 billion settlement fund for victims.
  • Zogg Fire (2020): 4 people killed. Manslaughter charges filed against PG&E.

PG&E's equipment has been found responsible for more than 1,500 wildfires in California between 2014 and 2020.[25]

Orange County Bankruptcy (1994)

Largest Municipal Bankruptcy in American History (at the time)

Orange County, California declared bankruptcy on December 6, 1994 after sustaining $1.64 billion in investment losses. County Treasurer Robert Citron had leveraged the county's investment pool to between 158% and 292% of its actual value using risky derivative instruments, essentially gambling with public funds. When interest rates rose, the leveraged positions collapsed. Citron pleaded guilty to six felonies but was sentenced to only 1 year of house arrest and a $100,000 fine; no prison time. The county did not fully pay off the bankruptcy-related debt until 2017, twenty-two years after the collapse.[26]

Washington, D.C.

  • Trayon White Sr. (Council Member, Ward 8); arrested in 2024 on federal bribery charges involving $156,000 in payments. All of his Council colleagues voted to recommend his expulsion.[27]
  • Jack Evans (longest-serving DC Council member); resigned in 2020 amid multiple ethics violations after investigations revealed he had used his Council position to benefit private business clients.

Miami / South Florida

  • Joe Martinez (Former Miami-Dade Commissioner); convicted November 2024 of unlawful compensation and conspiracy. Accepted $15,000 in bribes. Sentenced to approximately 3 years state prison.[28]
  • Frank Artiles (Former State Senator); found guilty September 30, 2024 of three felonies for orchestrating a "ghost candidate" scheme. Artiles paid $44,000 to a no-party candidate named Alex Rodriguez; the same name as the incumbent senator; to enter the race and siphon votes. The ghost candidate drew over 6,000 votes while the real incumbent lost by just 32 votes. Sentenced to 60 days jail plus 5 years probation.[29]

Atlanta, Georgia

  • Mitzi Bickers (Former Director of Human Services); found guilty March 2022 on 9 of 12 counts including money laundering, wire fraud, and bribery conspiracy.
  • Jimmie Beard (Former CFO); 3 years federal prison for theft, illegal purchase of machine guns, and tax obstruction.
  • Adam Smith (Chief Procurement Officer); 2 years federal prison for accepting $40,000+ in bribes in exchange for steering city contracts.
  • Antonio Brown (City Council Member); 18 months probation for bank fraud (2023).[30]

Denver, Colorado

  • Tina Peters (Mesa County Clerk), convicted August 2024 of seven charges including criminal attempt to influence a public servant and official misconduct. Peters gave unauthorized access to election equipment to individuals aligned with election denial conspiracies, compromising the security of the county's voting systems. Sentenced to 9 years in state prison, among the harshest sentences for any official involved in post-2020 election interference.[31]

State Legislature Corruption Patterns

State legislatures are particularly vulnerable to corruption for structural reasons: many are part-time, members are poorly compensated relative to the lobbying interests they attract, and media coverage is minimal.

Notable Cases

Sheldon Silver (D-NY)
Speaker, New York State Assembly (1994–2015)
82
Convicted Honest Services Fraud Extortion
Silver steered state grants to a doctor who referred asbestos cases to Silver's law firm, then steered tax benefits to a real estate developer who referred tax work to another law firm that paid Silver referral fees. Total estimated benefit: approximately $4 million in referral fees. He was convicted twice (the first conviction was overturned following McDonnell and he was retried and convicted again). Died in 2022 while serving a 6.5-year sentence.[8]
Dean Skelos (R-NY)
Majority Leader, New York State Senate (2008–2015)
68
Convicted Extortion Bribery
Convicted (also twice, also retried after McDonnell) of extortion and bribery for pressuring businesses with state matters before him to provide payments and employment to his son. The back-to-back convictions of the top legislative leaders in both chambers made New York a case study in state legislative corruption.

Other documented state legislative corruption cases:

  • Pennsylvania: The "Bonusgate" scandal (2007–2012) resulted in the conviction of 25 state legislators and staffers for using public employees and taxpayer funds for political campaign work.
  • Alabama: "Operation Gambling" (2010) led to the indictment of 11 individuals, including state legislators, on charges of vote-buying related to a gambling bill. Most were acquitted, but the investigation documented extensive cash payments to legislators.
  • Massachusetts: Three consecutive Speakers of the Massachusetts House were convicted of federal crimes: Charles Flaherty (tax evasion, 1996), Thomas Finneran (obstruction of justice, 2004), and Salvatore DiMasi (extortion and fraud, 2011).[9]

Local Law Enforcement Corruption

Local law enforcement corruption is among the most consequential and least systematically studied forms of public corruption. There is no federal database that comprehensively tracks police corruption nationwide. What exists are case studies, academic analyses, and DOJ pattern-or-practice investigations.

Documented Patterns

  • Drug-related corruption: The most common form. Officers steal drugs or cash from suspects, provide protection to drug dealers, or sell seized drugs. A 2020 Bowling Green State University database of police crimes identified over 1,000 drug-related corruption cases from 2005 to 2016.[10]
  • Evidence planting: Documented in multiple jurisdictions. In 2017, body camera footage from Baltimore revealed officers planting drugs at scenes; the resulting investigation led to the prosecution of the Gun Trace Task Force, a specialized unit whose members were convicted of racketeering, robbery, and extortion.
  • Overtime fraud: Systematic in many departments. Boston police overtime fraud was documented in a 2018 Boston Globe investigation that found officers routinely claimed overtime for shifts they did not work, costing the city millions annually.

DOJ Pattern-or-Practice Investigations

Under 34 U.S.C. 12601, the DOJ can investigate law enforcement agencies for "patterns or practices" of constitutional violations. Since 1994, the DOJ has opened over 70 such investigations, resulting in consent decrees or settlement agreements with dozens of departments. Key findings from selected investigations:

Department Year Key Findings
Los Angeles (Rampart Division) 2000 Officers planted evidence, shot unarmed suspects, and lied in court. Over 100 convictions overturned.
New Orleans PD 2011 Pattern of unreasonable force, unconstitutional stops/searches, and discriminatory policing.
Ferguson, MO 2015 Revenue-driven policing: police and courts used as a revenue extraction system targeting Black residents. Municipal court issued 32,975 warrants for a population of 21,000.
Chicago PD 2017 Pattern of unreasonable force, inadequate training, and accountability failures.
Baltimore PD 2016 Unconstitutional stops, excessive force, and discriminatory policing. Gun Trace Task Force convicted of racketeering.
Minneapolis PD 2023 Pattern of unjustified deadly force, discrimination against Black and Native American residents, free speech violations. Consent decree approved Jan 2025; Trump DOJ moved to dismiss.

The Quiet Corruption: Zoning, Contracts, and Permits

The least dramatic but most pervasive form of local corruption involves the routine exercise of discretionary government authority: zoning decisions, building permits, government contracts, and code enforcement. These decisions involve enormous financial stakes, a zoning change can add millions to a property's value, and are made by officials with broad discretion and minimal oversight.

Zoning and Land Use

Zoning decisions are among the most financially consequential actions local government takes. A variance or rezoning can transform a $500,000 lot into a $5 million development site. The incentives for corruption are obvious.

  • New York City: A 2019 investigation by The City and ProPublica documented a pattern of city planning officials leaving for private development firms that had matters before the agencies they had just left.
  • Los Angeles: City Councilman Jose Huizar was indicted in 2020 on racketeering charges for accepting $1.5 million in bribes from real estate developers seeking favorable zoning decisions. Convicted in 2024.[11]

Government Contracts

Local government contracting is the single largest category of state/local corruption prosecutions. Common patterns include:

  • Bid rigging: Steering contracts to favored companies through manipulated bidding processes.
  • Kickbacks: Officials receiving a percentage of contract value from winning bidders.
  • Ghost contracts: Payments for services never rendered.
  • Minority/disadvantaged business fraud: Using front companies to meet diversity requirements while the actual work is performed by disqualified firms.

Permits and Code Enforcement

Building permits and code enforcement create opportunities for petty corruption that, in aggregate, can be massive. The typical pattern involves inspectors accepting payments to overlook code violations or expedite permits. In 2015, an FBI investigation in the New York City Department of Buildings revealed a scheme in which inspectors were accepting bribes of $100 to $10,000 per inspection to approve substandard construction.[12]

State-by-State Ethics Law Comparison

The Center for Public Integrity, in partnership with Global Integrity, conducted the most comprehensive state-by-state assessment of corruption risk in 2015. The study evaluated each state on 245 indicators across 13 categories. The results were damning: only three states received an overall grade above D+.[13]

Rank State Grade Strongest Area Weakest Area
1 Alaska C Financial disclosure Lobbying disclosure
2 California C- Public access to information Judicial accountability
3 Connecticut C- Ethics enforcement Electoral oversight
48 Wyoming F N/A (no category above D) Ethics enforcement / Lobbying
49 Michigan F Public access to information Financial disclosure
50 Delaware F N/A Nearly every category

Key disparities between states:

  • Financial disclosure: Some states (California, New York) require detailed asset, income, and liability disclosure from officials. Others (Idaho, Wyoming, Michigan) require little or nothing.
  • Gift restrictions: Range from total bans (South Carolina) to no restrictions at all (several states).
  • Cooling-off periods: Range from two years (some states) to zero (many states have no post-government lobbying restrictions for state legislators).
  • Independent audit: Only 33 states have an independent Inspector General or equivalent. The remaining 17 rely on internal auditing or have no systematic audit function.
The Correlation Between Weak Ethics Laws and High Corruption There is no one-to-one correlation between strong ethics laws and low corruption — New York has strong ethics laws and high corruption. However, states with the weakest ethics frameworks consistently appear in the bottom half of corruption rankings, because weak laws mean fewer cases are investigated and prosecuted, not that fewer corrupt acts occur. The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Sources

  1. [1] Academic Abernathy, Penelope Muse. "The State of Local News 2022." Northwestern University Medill School of Journalism (2022).
  2. [2] Academic Gao, Pengjie, Chang Lee, and Dermot Murphy. "Financing Dies in Darkness? The Impact of Newspaper Closures on Public Finance." Journal of Financial Economics 135, no. 2 (2020): 445–467.
  3. [3] Data National Conference of State Legislatures, "Ethics: State Ethics Commissions" (2023 update).
  4. [4] Journalism Meisner, Jason. "Former Ald. Ed Burke Found Guilty of Racketeering." Chicago Tribune, December 21, 2023; DOJ Northern District of Illinois public corruption statistics.
  5. [5] Academic Simpson, Dick, et al. "Corruption in the Land of Lincoln and the State of Illinois." University of Illinois at Chicago, Anti-Corruption Report No. 12 (2019).
  6. [6] Court U.S. Attorney's Office, District of New Jersey, "Operation Bid Rig III" press releases (2009); United States v. Addonizio, 451 F.2d 49 (3d Cir. 1971).
  7. [7] Court United States v. Kilpatrick, No. 10-20403 (E.D. Mich. 2013).
  8. [8] Court United States v. Silver, No. 15-cr-093 (S.D.N.Y. 2015, retried 2018).
  9. [9] Journalism Levenson, Michael. "Why the Third Consecutive Mass. House Speaker Was Convicted." Boston Globe, June 28, 2011; Pennsylvania Office of the Attorney General, "Bonusgate" case summary (2012).
  10. [10] Academic Stinson, Philip M. "Police Crime Database." Bowling Green State University, Criminal Justice Faculty Publications (2005–2020).
  11. [11] Court United States v. Huizar, No. 20-cr-326 (C.D. Cal. 2020).
  12. [12] Journalism Rosenthal, Brian M. "They Went to Work for the City and Made Themselves Rich." New York Times, December 28, 2019 (NYC Department of Buildings investigation).
  13. [13] Data Center for Public Integrity, "State Integrity Investigation 2015." publicintegrity.org/state-politics.
  14. [14] Court United States v. Jenkins et al., No. 17-cr-079 (D. Md. 2017); Fenton, Justin. We Own This City: A True Story of Crime, Cops, and Corruption. Random House (2021).
  15. [15] Court United States v. Pugh, No. 19-cr-450 (D. Md. 2019); DOJ Press Release, "Former Baltimore Mayor Catherine Pugh Sentenced to Three Years in Federal Prison" (Feb. 27, 2020).
  16. [16] Court United States v. Johnson, No. 10-cr-718 (D. Md. 2011); Wagner, John. "Jack Johnson, Former Prince George's County Executive, Sentenced to 87 Months." Washington Post, December 6, 2011.
  17. [17] Government U.S. Department of Justice, "Investigation of the City of Minneapolis and the Minneapolis Police Department" (June 16, 2023); Consent Decree, United States v. City of Minneapolis, No. 23-cv-1461 (D. Minn. Jan. 6, 2025).
  18. [18] Court United States v. Bock et al., No. 22-cr-223 (D. Minn. 2022); DOJ Press Release, "Leaders of Feeding Our Future Found Guilty" (March 19, 2025).
  19. [19] Journalism Montemayor, Stephen and Andy Mannix. "Minnesota's Massive Fraud Problem." Star Tribune (ongoing investigative series, 2023–2025); U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, "Pandemic Fraud" hearing testimony (2024).
  20. [20] Court United States v. Huizar, No. 20-cr-326 (C.D. Cal. 2020); DOJ Press Release, "Former Los Angeles City Councilman Jose Huizar Sentenced to 13 Years" (Jan. 2024).
  21. [21] Court United States v. Ridley-Thomas, No. 21-cr-478 (C.D. Cal. 2021); Zahniser, David. "Mark Ridley-Thomas Found Guilty of Bribery, Conspiracy." Los Angeles Times, March 2024.
  22. [22] Court United States v. Nuru, No. 20-cr-040 (N.D. Cal. 2020); Knight, Heather. "Mohammed Nuru Sentenced to 7 Years." San Francisco Chronicle, August 2023.
  23. [23] Court People v. Rizzo, No. BA376025 (L.A. Super. Ct. 2010); Gottlieb, Jeff. "Bell's Robert Rizzo Gets 12 Years in Prison." Los Angeles Times, April 16, 2014.
  24. [24] Court United States v. Yee, No. 14-cr-196 (N.D. Cal. 2014); DOJ Press Release, "Former California State Senator Leland Yee Sentenced to Five Years" (Feb. 24, 2016).
  25. [25] Court People v. Pacific Gas & Electric Company, No. 20-cr-3953 (Butte County Super. Ct. 2020); CPUC investigation reports (2010–2021); United States v. Pacific Gas & Electric Company, No. 14-cr-175 (N.D. Cal. 2016).
  26. [26] Academic Jorion, Philippe. Big Bets Gone Bad: Derivatives and Bankruptcy in Orange County. Academic Press (1995); Baldassare, Mark. When Government Fails: The Orange County Bankruptcy. University of California Press (1998).
  27. [27] Journalism Austermuhle, Martin. "Trayon White Arrested on Federal Bribery Charges." WAMU/DCist (2024); D.C. Council Resolution on Expulsion Recommendation (2024).
  28. [28] Court State of Florida v. Martinez, No. F24-018745 (Miami-Dade Cir. Ct. 2024).
  29. [29] Court State of Florida v. Artiles, No. F21-007381 (Miami-Dade Cir. Ct. 2021); Mazzei, Patricia. "Frank Artiles Found Guilty of Ghost Candidate Scheme." Miami Herald, September 30, 2024.
  30. [30] Court United States v. Bickers, No. 19-cr-400 (N.D. Ga. 2019); Prabhu, Maya T. "Atlanta Procurement Officer Sentenced to Two Years." Atlanta Journal-Constitution (2022).
  31. [31] Court People v. Peters, No. 22-cr-56 (Mesa County Dist. Ct. 2022); Stahl, Jeremy. "Tina Peters Sentenced to 9 Years for Election Machine Tampering." Slate, October 3, 2024.
  32. [32] Court Cumming et al. v. Mayor & City Council of Baltimore City, Baltimore Circuit Court (filed Feb. 24, 2026); Richman, Fern Shen. "Inspector General Files Lawsuit Against City Over Access to Records." Baltimore Brew, February 24, 2026.
  33. [33] Journalism Baltimore Brew (multiple articles, 2025–2026): reporting on IG obstruction, campaign finance violations, and the J.P. Grant donation; Fox Baltimore (multiple reports, 2025–2026): investigative coverage of Scott administration controversies.
  34. [34] Government Baltimore City Office of Inspector General, Report on MONSE/SideStep Program Fraud (2026); OIG Report on Mayor's Office Spending, February 25, 2026; CBS Baltimore, "OIG Report Reveals $890K in Mayor's Office Spending" (Feb. 2026).
  35. [35] Journalism Baltimore Sun editorial board, coverage of Safe Streets program and FBI raid (2023–2024); OIG Safe Streets Fictitious Names Report (Nov. 2024); Baltimore City Department of Audits, Safe Streets duplicate payments finding.
  36. [36] Journalism Baltimore Banner, reporting on the $163,495 Jeep Grand Wagoneer purchase and Bmore Empowered nonprofit conflicts (2025–2026); Fox Baltimore, investigation of BCYF board ties to mayor's office.
  37. [37] Journalism WMAR (ABC2 Baltimore), reporting on Calvin Young hiring, ethics disclosure failure, and EEOC complaint (2024–2025); Baltimore Brew, "Mayor's Campaign Treasurer Hired as Senior Advisor" (2024).
  38. [38] Government Baltimore City State's Attorney's Office, press release on termination of MONSE coordination (Dec. 2025); Baltimore Banner, "State's Attorney Bates Accuses MONSE of Operating Behind 'Veil of Secrecy'" (Dec. 2025).